Home
Search AIMP site
Poscasts
Job Offerings
Industry News
Latin Corner

Copyright Corner

EVENTS

October 27, 2016

Time: 3:00 p.m. - 5:00 p.m.

Copyright Infringement Lawsuits: Why Some Win (Blurred Lines), Why Some Lose (Led Zeppelin), and What’s Next (LA)

 3:00 p.m. - 5:00 p.m.

The Beverly Hilton
9876 Wilshire Blvd.
Beverly Hills, CA 90210

 
There have been several high profile music copyright infringement decisions recently that have the public and industry buzzing. Unfortunately, the media, and others discussing the cases, often times get the facts underlying those decisions wrong. This leaves the public, and even songwriters, and others in the industry, with the wrong impression about the facts, the law, and the evidence on which decisions are based.
 
AIMP Members, you are invited to join Richard S. Busch, of King & Ballow, the lead litigator in the “Blurred Lines” case, among other noteworthy cases, as he discusses the facts of the "Blurred Lines" case, as well as important evidentiary rulings made in that case, and the evidence that supported the jury verdict in favor of the Gaye family, which was then confirmed by the District Judge.  In addition, musicologist, Judith Finell, will be presenting, detailing some of the key facts from the Blurred Lines case.   Mr. Busch will also be discussing the important issues on appeal in "Blurred Lines," as well as his take on other recent cases, including the recently decided "Led Zeppelin" case, and his view on the important issues that will be litigated in future copyright infringement lawsuits.  
 
To RSVP for this free event, log in to your Member's Area for the link. 
 

 

Richard S. Busch is a Partner in the Litigation Section and is Head of the Entertainment and Intellectual Property Sections of King & Ballow. His practice areas include Litigation (State and Federal), Entertainment Litigation, Intellectual Property Litigation, and Commercial Litigation. Prior to joining the firm in 1991, Mr. Busch served as Law Clerk to the Honorable John V. Parker, Chief Judge of the United States District Court for the Middle District of Louisiana.

Mr. Busch received his law degree from Loyola University Law School where he was a member of the Loyola University Law Review and the Moot Court Board, serving as Spring National Team Coach. In addition, Mr. Busch received the American Jurisprudence Award for Secured Transactions and the Fishman Award as the outstanding commercial law student.

Mr. Busch has successfully represented music clients in numerous trial and appellate court cases. In the action styled F.B.T. Productions, LLC v. Aftermath Records, et al., Mr. Busch represented the Plaintiff, who discovered, produced, and co-wrote some of recording artist Eminem’s biggest hits, in the landmark case, in which the United States Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit entered judgment in favor of F.B.T., finding that the agreements between record label Universal and digital download providers like iTunes, are licenses, and Eminem’s recording agreement entitles him and F.B.T. to 50 percent of Universal’s net receipts for sales by iTunes and others of Eminem songs. The full decision may be found at 2010 U.S. App. LEXIS 18450 (9th Cir. Sept. 3, 2010). Mr. Busch is currently representing many other artists in similar lawsuits and in connection with similar claims.

Mr. Busch also represented Eminem’s music publisher, Eight Mile Style in a copyright infringement action against Apple, Inc. and Aftermath Records in a trial involving whether Apple obtained the necessary publishing licenses allowing it to make Eminem songs available for digital download on iTunes. The trial settled after nearly a week of testimony.

Mr. Busch also represented Bridgeport Music, Inc. and Westbound Records, Inc. in a copyright infringement action against Bad Boy Records, the record label owned by Sean “Diddy” Combs, and Universal Music in a trial that resulted in a $4.4 million jury award in favor of Bridgeport Music and Westbound, including a finding of willful copyright infringement against the Defendants, all arising from the "sampling" in the Notorious B.I.G. song Ready To Die. Mr. Busch also represented Bridgeport Music in a copyright infringement trial against Universal Music involving the unlawful copying of portions of the Bridgeport Music's song Atomic Dog. The jury returned a finding of willful copyright infringement against the Defendants in that action as well. The United States Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit later affirmed the decision, finding that copyright infringement may occur by the copying of a single common word such as "dog," if the alleged infringer uses that word in the new composition in the same way as it was used in the original musical composition. The Sixth Circuit also found that Universal Music committed willful copyright infringement when it copied the signature phrase from Atomic Dog without permission, rejecting Universal Music's Fair Use, and De Minimis defenses. The full decision may be found at Bridgeport Music, Inc. v. UMG Recordings, Inc., 585 F.3d 267 (6th Cir. 2009). Billboard Magazine identified this decision as one of the five most important judicial decisions of 2009, and noted that it will change the way the music industry operates.

Mr. Busch was also Lead Counsel in the action entitled Bridgeport Music, Inc., et al. v. Dimension Films, et. al., 2004 U.S. App. LEXIS 18810; 2004 FED App. 0297P (6th Cir.), where he successfully argued and obtained the landmark ruling by the United States Court of Appeals that there is no de minimis defense in a copyright infringement action to sampling or copying of a sound recording.

In the Fall of 2012, Mr. Busch obtained a federal court jury verdict in favor of his client, Alvert Music, for more than $2 million, together with a finding of willful copyright infringement, against the Defendant record company, in a case involving an interplay of bankruptcy and copyright issues.

Most recently, Mr. Busch obtained a jury award of $7.4 million in favor of the heirs of Marvin Gaye against Pharrell Williams and Robin Thicke arising out of the unlawful copying of Marvin Gaye's classic hit Got to Give It Up in the song Blurred Lines.

In addition to copyright, intellectual property, and entertainment litigation, Mr. Busch has successfully represented numerous clients in Federal Court in commercial litigation cases across the country. Mr. Busch served as Lead Counsel in a bad faith insurance action against Travelers’ Insurance Company in the Northern District of California, in which the jury returned a verdict in favor of Mr. Busch's client, and against Travelers’ Insurance Company, including a punitive damage award of more than $4 million. Mr. Busch also obtained a punitive damage award in favor of his client in a malicious breach of contract action tried in Federal Court in the Northern District of Ohio. Mr. Busch also represented Tribune Company in a 600 defendant civil racketeering action in the Southern District of New York in which the defendants were accused of conspiring to file fraudulent workers' compensation claims. That case was settled prior to trial.

For his work on the F.B.T. case, and other litigation successes, including the recent "Blurred Lines" case, Mr. Busch was named one of the top 100 Entertainment Power Lawyers by The Hollywood Reporter in 2012, 2013, 2014, and 2015. He was also named by Variety Magazine on their Power 50 list as one of the top 50 entertainment lawyers in the country in 2015. Mr. Busch was named by Billboard Magazine as one of the “Music's Most Powerful Attorneys” in 2015, where he was one of only four litigators named. He was also named by Billboard Magazine on their Power 100 list as one of the most influential people in the music business in 2012. Mr. Busch has also been featured on numerous occasions as one of the best 150 lawyers in Tennessee in Business Tennessee magazine.

Mr. Busch was featured in The Variety Legal Impact Report 2015.  The feature can be seen here.

Members
 
Members:
Login now to register for events and access your members area.
AIMP Twitter follow page AIMP Linked In group page AIMP Facebook page
Calendar of Events
Articles
Members Blog Posts
Entertainment Law Fundamentals and Practice by Corey Field (New publication)
by C. Field
View Full Post

Meta-Metadata: Turning Three Text Fields Into Millions of Dollars
by C. Crawford
View Full Post

See all Posts
Legislation
Court of Appeals Sides With Songwriters, Publishers on Licensing As the music industry headed into the holiday season, the U.S. Second Circuit Court of Appeals gave songwriters and music publishe …

View More

State Department Pays WIPO Dues The Copyright Alliance reported that last week, they were notified that after completing its review of World Intellectual Property …

View More